Important Information Before We Get Into The Data
Please note, the full set of Constrained Layer Damper sound deadener product comparisons can be found on our Independent Sound Deadener Testing Page.
Let’s clear up some things before we get into any of the data…
- ResoNix does NOT do the independent testing that is shown on our site. It is genuinely from a third party who is completely unaffiliated with ResoNix.
- Chris Purdue, admin and founder of the Facebook group, “The Deadening” is the one who does the testing.
- ResoNix Sound Solutions has NOTHING to do with the testing, Chris, or anything related. We just share the results from his test, and help break down the data for end users to understand.
- Chris has ZERO affiliation to ResoNix Sound Solutions.
- ResoNix does not have ANY control whatsoever of what Chris tests, how Chris tests, or what results he shows.
- From what we understand, Chris gets zero monetary benefit out of his testing. He claims to do it because years ago he was sick of the deceit of many of the sound deadener product companies that existed in the market, and he wanted to find out for himself what products performed the best, and it sort of grew into what it is today.
- Again, Nick/ResoNix and Chris Purdue (the Chris who does the testing) have ZERO affiliation, business or personal outside of interactions in his Facebook group.
- Just to be safe I will say it one more time: ResoNix has nothing to do with the testing being done by Chris, and Chris has nothing to do with ResoNix.
- In another language for good measure: ResoNix no tiene nada que ver con las pruebas que realiza Chris, y Chris no tiene nada que ver con ResoNix.
Understood? Cool, let’s move on.
What Constrained Layer Dampers Are, How They Work, Why We Care, & How It Relates To Your Project.
Bullet point summary since most people prefer to skim and refuse to read (please actually read the whole thing, I promise it’ll help make sense of everything)
- Resonance Basics: Vehicle panels vibrate at certain “preferred” frequencies, causing structural noise (buzzing, rattling, “ringing”) that degrades the listening environment.
- Role of CLD: Constrained Layer Dampers address structural resonance by converting the panel’s vibrational energy into heat. This reduces how much the panel “rings,” leading to a quieter, more stable surface.
- Not Airborne Noise Control: CLD does not block or absorb outside sounds or general airborne noise—it only minimizes structural vibration within the panel material itself.
- CLD does NOT work by adding weight: While adding weight can help reduce resonance, it is a largely inefficient way to reduce resonance. Constrained layer damping is much more efficient for a given amount of weight, and is why they exist in the first place and work by constraining a panel using the shear forces generated by the viscoelastic properties of the butyl combined with the stiff aluminum constraining layer. This combination resists flex when adhered to a panel.
- Importance of Quality & Testing: Reliable testing, like that found on the linked ResoNix Sound Deadening Independent Testing Page, helps confirm which CLD products genuinely reduce structural resonance and maintain effectiveness under real-world conditions.
.
Before we get into what Constrained Layer Dampers are, we need to understand what they are targeting – Resonance.
Resonance occurs when something vibrates at its preferred frequency (known as its resonance frequency, or FS), often amplifying and sustaining that motion. Think of a simple example: if you gently push a swing at just the right moment each time, it starts to move higher and higher. In the context of car audio and vehicle interior noise, certain panels or surfaces vibrate in response to bumps, mechanical movement, or sound waves. When these and other external forces act upon this panel, the panel will “ring” or resonate. This can cause audible resonance, buzzing, rattling, or a sense of “tinny” harshness that spoils your listening experience and makes the cabin feel louder than it should.
Understanding resonance is crucial because it’s the root cause of much of the unwanted noise you hear inside a vehicle. Without controlling it, even the best sound system can be overshadowed by rattling panels, dull thuds, and persistent buzzing at certain notes or frequencies. During normal driving, it can be heard as drone and be loud, overbearing, and generally unpleasant all around. By identifying and addressing resonance, you can prevent panels from acting like drumheads, ensuring a quieter, more pleasant environment, whether you’re enjoying music, talking with passengers, or simply enjoying a normal daily drive.
This is where Constrained Layer Dampers come in to save the day. Here is an excerpt from the general synopsis of the ResoNix Sound Deadening Materials Reference Information & Guide article.
“Constrained Layer Damper (CLD) materials, like ResoNix CLD Squares or ResoNix Mega CLD Squares, reduce structural resonance of panels. They consist of a visco-elastic butyl rubber layer bonded to an aluminum constraining layer. When panels that have a CLD applied flex (resonate), the butyl stretches and resists with shear forces due to the visco-elasticity of the butyl combined with the reference of the aluminum’s stiffness, converting mechanical energy into heat. Applied to metal and plastic panels such as doors, trunk lids, floors, various trim panels, and roofs, CLD is typically the first sound treatment used.
In car audio, CLD prevents rattling and resonance from powerful speakers, reducing distortion and improving sound quality. During regular driving, it reduces noise from wind, turbulence, and mechanical vibrations, lowering the overall noise floor. Larger, continuous pieces are more effective than multiple small ones, and only one layer is necessary for effective damping.
CLD does not block external noise but reduces the resonance of the panels it covers. It should not be heated during installation, and surfaces must be clean for proper adhesion. High-quality CLD resists melting and maintains performance at high temperatures; low-quality products may melt, off-gas, and have reduced damping effectiveness. Avoid products that come in rolls or have embossed patterns, as these can compromise the material’s performance.
Specifically designed to lower structure-borne vibrations, CLD will not block road noise or prevent panel-on-panel vibration by itself. Roofing products from big box stores are unsuitable substitutes, lacking the necessary visco-elastic properties and potentially being toxic. Investing in high-quality CLD materials from reputable companies ensures better performance and longevity, avoiding issues associated with cheaper alternatives.
In summary, properly applied CLD reduces vehicle panel resonance, improving audio quality and reducing noise generated by the vehicle itself. Use single layers of large pieces on clean surfaces without heating the material. High-quality CLD offers superior performance and durability, making it a worthwhile investment over lower-quality options that may fail under automotive conditions.”
How Does Resonance Reduction With Sound Deadener Help You?
How this relates to your use is pretty simple. Lets break it down into two categories: Sound Systems, and General Driving Noise Reduction.
When it comes to enhancing a car audio system, reducing resonance in the vehicle’s metal body panels and plastic trim helps ensure that the sounds you’re hearing come primarily from the speakers, not from vibrating surfaces. This is, in most cases, going to attribute to the largest reduction in distortion in your sound system compared to any other upgrade in said sound system. Without proper damping, these panels will resonate, or “ring” like unwanted instruments, adding distortion to your music and obscuring detail. By applying a high-quality Constrained Layer Damper such as the offerings from ResoNix, you significantly decrease the panel’s ability to resonate, which results in tighter bass, clarifying midrange and treble, and lowering overall distortion in the entire system. In other words, resonance reduction with a constrained layer damper keeps the panels from interfering, so the speakers can do their job, and you can focus on the music as it’s meant to be heard.
Separately, reducing resonance inside the vehicle also makes regular driving quieter and more pleasant. There are many forces and forms of mechanical disturbance that cause panels to resonate. This resonance is audible, with the panel acting as a speaker and raises the vehicle’s overall noise floor. With proper damping, these structural vibrations are minimized, leaving you with a lower overall noise floor, and less sources of noise for a more peaceful cabin environment. So while the approach is similar, applying damping materials to control unwanted resonance, the goal for daily driving comfort is different, focusing on lowering the general level of cabin noise, not just improving the audio system’s performance.
That being said, the noise reductions you see on the Independent Test Results page do NOT mean that if you use X product, that you are going to have Y noise reduction. The test purely shows how much energy a given constrained layer damper is able to remove from a panel. Reminder: constrained layer dampers do NOT block or absorb outside noise. They only reduce structural resonance. How much noise a constrained layer damper will remove from your car while driving, or from a sound system upgrades perspective is PURELY dependent on how much noise is being caused by resonance in the first place. To read more about how you can properly reduce not only structural resonance in your vehicle, but also how you can reduce airborne noise, check out the ResoNix Buyers Guide, and ResoNix Sound Deadening Materials Reference Information & Guide articles.
The dB Scale, How It Works, & How It Relates To The Testing
Bullet point summary:
- dB = Logarithmic: The decibel scale measures energy on a logarithmic curve, not a linear straight line. A 3dB increase represents double the energy; a 3dB decrease represents half of the energy. 100dB isn’t just twice as loud as 50dB, it’s far more powerful than that. =10^(dB/10) is the formula for those who wish to know
- Human Hearing & The dB Scale: While 3dB increases represent 2x the amount of energy, our ears do NOT perceive a 3dB increase as twice as loud. 10dB is actually considered twice as loud when perceived by human hearing.
- Testing CLD: By measuring how much a panel’s resonance peak is reduced in dB, we know how effective the product is at cutting unwanted vibrations.
- 2x Energy Measured vs. 2x Energy As Heard By Our Ears: While human hearing roughly perceives a 10dB increase as “twice as loud,” the testing of CLD products focuses on changes in the physical energy of panel vibrations, where every 3dB represents a doubling or halving of that energy. In other words, using perceived loudness doesn’t accurately track or reflect the actual performance and effectiveness of these materials in reducing structural resonance.
.
The decibel (dB) scale is a way of measuring the loudness or intensity of a sound using a logarithmic, rather than linear, scale. Instead of adding equal amounts to get louder results, each small step in dB represents a change in the energy behind the sound. For example, every 3dB increase represents a doubling of the sound’s energy, and every 3dB decrease represents cutting that energy in half. This means that 100dB isn’t just twice as loud as 50dB—it’s actually many times more powerful. In other words, what might seem like small changes in decibel values can actually represent big differences in how much sound energy is present.
When it comes to testing sound deadening materials, like those discussed in the article, understanding the dB scale is crucial. The tests measure how much a given material reduces the amplitude of a panel’s resonance at certain frequencies—often around 100Hz, common in car doors. By looking at how many decibels the “peak” of a panel’s ringing is reduced, we get a clear idea of how effective the sound deadening material really is. A material that brings a resonant peak down by 3dB cuts its energy in half, and one that reduces it by 6dB reduces it to a quarter of its original strength. This gives a simple but powerful way to compare products: the lower the resulting dB peak, the more effectively that product is taming resonance and preventing your car’s panels from acting like noisy drums.
The decibel scale isn’t just about how loud something “sounds” to human ears; it’s fundamentally about how much energy is present in a vibration or wave. While a 10dB difference is often discussed in terms of perceived loudness (about twice as loud to our ears), the key to testing panel resonance is that every 3dB increment actually doubles or halves the physical energy involved. This is critical because when we reduce panel resonance, we’re targeting the mechanical energy that causes the panel to vibrate and “ring,” not just how it seems to our ears. A 3dB decrease may not feel like a huge drop in loudness on paper, but in terms of energy, it represents a 50% reduction in the vibrational force at that frequency, an essential point when evaluating how effectively a product is taming the structural resonance that leads to unwanted noise.
How The Testing Results Are Determined
& How The "Performance Multiplier" Works
Bullet point summary:
- 3dB Doubling Rule: Every 3dB change represents a doubling or halving of the vibrational energy.
- Comparing Reductions: A product that reduces resonance by 17dB compared to another at 14dB is 2x as effective (3dB difference = 2x), while going from 17dB to 11dB (6dB difference) results in 4x the effectiveness.
- Practical Impact: Using these multipliers makes it easier to understand and compare the true effectiveness of different CLD products, rather than just looking at raw dB numbers.
.
The testing results use the 3dB doubling rule as a baseline. Every 3dB difference in reduction represents a doubling of performance in terms of how much structural resonance energy is reduced. To determine the “performance multiplier” between two products, you simply look at their difference in total dB reduction and apply this rule.
For example, if ResoNix CLD Squares reduce resonance by 17dB and another product reduces it by 14dB, that’s a 3dB difference. Three decibels represent a doubling of energy reduction, so ResoNix is effectively 2x more effective than that product. If another product only reduces the resonance by 11dB (6dB less than ResoNix), then you have two sets of 3dB differences: 3dB + 3dB = 6dB. Since 3dB is double and 6dB is double again (2 x 2 = 4), that makes ResoNix 4x more effective.
For example, comparing ResoNix CLD Squares to Dynamat Extreme: ResoNix achieves a 17dB reduction while Dynamat manages only an 8dB reduction, for a difference of 9dB total. Since every 3dB step represents doubling, three steps (3dB + 3dB + 3dB = 9dB) amount to an 8x multiplier (2 x 2 x 2 = 8). This means ResoNix CLD Squares are 8 times as effective at reducing structural resonance as Dynamat Extreme, making it much more efficient on a per-area basis.
"Okay Then, Prove It"
An Example Shown By One Of Chris's Rounds Of Testing
Below is a test that was done by Chris and posted on September 10th, 2023. This test was a bit different than his usual tests where he tests one product vs another in a comparable way, where each product is cut to the same size, and placed in the same spot on the same test panel. For this test, he wanted to see how much material and coverage of other products it would take to match the performance of a given piece of ResoNix CLD Squares and ResoNix Mega CLD Squares.
Chris’s own words from his post…
“I’ve said repeatedly that budget products may not always be cheaper if your intentions are to get the same results using more product. What does that mean? That it may cost more to buy enough of a cheap product to match the performance of a better product. That idea has always gotten push back, so I decided to take to of the highest reviewed “budget” products on Amazon, and compare it to the current highest performing (and highest cost) products.
- To start, Resonix is $8.50/sq foot, and Resonix Mega is $11.75/sq foot. Killmat 80mil is $1.38/sq foot. Noico is $4.02/sq foot.
- ResoNix CLD Squares (30.25 Square inches, ~94 grams) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 16.50db.
- ResoNix Mega CLD Squares (30.25 Square inches, ~105 grams) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 19.29db.
- The first layer of Killmat (100 Square Inches, ~143 grams) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 9.00db.
- The second layer of Killmat (200 Square Inches, ~286 grams total) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 16.18db.
- The third layer of Killmat (300 Square Inches, ~429 grams total) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 20.68db.
- The first layer of Noico (100 Square Inches, ~145 grams) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 11.88db.
- The second layer of Noico (200 Square Inches, ~290 grams total) reduced the resonant frequency of the test panel’s amplitude by 19.13db
.
Going off these tests it takes approximately 6.61 times as much Killmat 80mil to match the performance of Resonix. And it takes approximately 9.91 times as much Killmat 80mil to match the performance of Resonix Mega. This puts Killmat’s pricing at $9.12 to match the performance of one square foot of Resonix, and $13.68 to match the performance of one square foot of Resonix Mega. It takes 429 grams of Killmat to match the performance of 105 grams of Resonix Mega.
Pictures From Chris's Testing - Weight Of Final Amounts
Pictures From Chris's Testing - Frequency Response & Waterfall Graphs
The Measurements & Their Performance Translation
- Resonance Reduction (dB)
- Weight Equivalency Chart
- Sq. Ft. Equivalency Chart
ResoNix Mega CLD Squares
– 30.25 Square Inches,
~105 grams
19.29 dB reduction
ResoNix CLD Squares
– 30.25 Square Inches,
~94 grams
16.5 dB reduction
Kilmat – 100 Square Inches, ~143 grams
9 dB reduction
Kilmat – 200 Square Inches, ~286 grams
16.18 dB reduction
Kilmat 300 Square Inches, ~429 grams
20.68 dB reduction
Noico – 100 Square Inches, ~145 grams
11.88 dB reduction
Noico – 200 Square Inches, ~290 grams
19.13 dB reduction
The Measurements Of Sound Deadener Performance, & How To Interpret Them
Moving on to actually reading the results that are generated by Chris’s testing rig… The Decibel scale is measured logarithmic instead of linear. Every 3-decibel change, the energy is doubled or halved. If you have a speaker playing something at 85dB, twice the amount of energy is needed to hit 88dB. You will need twice the amount of power applied to the speaker or twice the number of speakers to achieve the 88dB. If you double the number of speakers and double the amount of power, that would be a 6dB addition. 50 decibels is NOT half as loud, or half the energy of 100 decibels. Pretty simple, right? Good. Let’s recap with bullet points real quick just in case.
- The decibel system is logarithmic, not linear.
- 3dB up is twice the energy. 3dB down is half the energy.
- 50dB is NOT half of 100dB. 25dB is not half of 50dB.
- 97dB is half the energy of 100dB. 103dB is 2x as much energy as 100dB.
- =10^(dB/10) is the formula for those who wish to know
ResoNix Mega CLD Squares
~105 grams
19.29 dB reduction
ResoNix CLD Squares
105 grams ÷ ~94 grams
(1.117 x multiplier)
18.43 dB reduction
Kilmat
105 grams ÷ ~143 grams
(0.734 x multiplier)
6.6 dB reduction
Kilmat
105 grams ÷ ~286 grams
(0.367 x multiplier)
5.9 dB reduction
Kilmat
105 grams ÷ ~429 grams
(0.245 x multiplier)
5.06 dB reduction
Noico
105 grams ÷ ~145 grams
(0.724 x multiplier)
8.6 dB reduction
Noico
105 grams ÷ ~290 grams
(0.362 x multiplier)
6.9 dB reduction
The Measurements Of Sound Deadener Performance, & How To Interpret Them
Moving on to actually reading the results that are generated by Chris’s testing rig… The Decibel scale is measured logarithmic instead of linear. Every 3-decibel change, the energy is doubled or halved. If you have a speaker playing something at 85dB, twice the amount of energy is needed to hit 88dB. You will need twice the amount of power applied to the speaker or twice the number of speakers to achieve the 88dB. If you double the number of speakers and double the amount of power, that would be a 6dB addition. 50 decibels is NOT half as loud, or half the energy of 100 decibels. Pretty simple, right? Good. Let’s recap with bullet points real quick just in case.
- The decibel system is logarithmic, not linear.
- 3dB up is twice the energy. 3dB down is half the energy.
- 50dB is NOT half of 100dB. 25dB is not half of 50dB.
- 97dB is half the energy of 100dB. 103dB is 2x as much energy as 100dB.
- =10^(dB/10) is the formula for those who wish to know
ResoNix Mega CLD Squares
30.25 Sq. Inches.
19.29 dB reduction
ResoNix CLD Squares
30.25 Sq. Inches.
18.43 dB reduction
Kilmat
30.25 ÷ 100 Sq. Inches
(0.3025 x multiplier)
2.72 dB reduction
Kilmat
30.25 ÷ 200 Sq. Inches
(0.1513 x multiplier)
2.45 dB reduction
Kilmat
30.25 ÷ 300 Sq. Inches
(0.1008 x multiplier)
2.08 dB reduction
Noico
30.25 ÷ 100 Sq. Inches
(0.3025 x multiplier)
3.57 dB reduction
Noico
30.25 ÷ 200 Sq. Inches
(0.1513 x multiplier)
2.89 dB reduction
The Measurements Of Sound Deadener Performance, & How To Interpret Them
Moving on to actually reading the results that are generated by Chris’s testing rig… The Decibel scale is measured logarithmic instead of linear. Every 3-decibel change, the energy is doubled or halved. If you have a speaker playing something at 85dB, twice the amount of energy is needed to hit 88dB. You will need twice the amount of power applied to the speaker or twice the number of speakers to achieve the 88dB. If you double the number of speakers and double the amount of power, that would be a 6dB addition. 50 decibels is NOT half as loud, or half the energy of 100 decibels. Pretty simple, right? Good. Let’s recap with bullet points real quick just in case.
- The decibel system is logarithmic, not linear.
- 3dB up is twice the energy. 3dB down is half the energy.
- 50dB is NOT half of 100dB. 25dB is not half of 50dB.
- 97dB is half the energy of 100dB. 103dB is 2x as much energy as 100dB.
- =10^(dB/10) is the formula for those who wish to know